Seven Fishes – I Secondi e Contorni

One common way we prepare fish for the Secondi in the Feast of the Seven Fishes is al cartocchio. I write about a similar recipe on Southern Ash using the more common French term en papillotte . This is where the cod comes into play, and had we spent several days soaking and draining baccala, it would have a home in the secondi. Two different preparations have been done over the years with our current pesce con cartocchio (Fish steamed in a pouch) and the former fish broiled in the adriatic way. If you have been paying attention, you may have noticed that the amount of food on the table is slowly reducing. While this is a large and long dinner, it is never intended to overwhelm so the secondi is a smaller portion than you my be used to but it comes after a round of three pastas and a dozen antipasti.

Pesce al Cartocchio

We’ve covered this dish before on Southern Ash. For Christmas Eve, the first thing is to remember that we use cod specifically because of the association salt cod has with the holiday, though we don’t want to do the days of soaking and draining required for salt cod. We also use some different components of the pouch because it is a special occasion. Specifically, the use of fennel fronds adds a lot of flavor and a blood orange slice in the packet as part of the citrus just makes the entire dish even prettier. With the contorni here, you also shouldn’t need to include any veggies in the packet. Go to the previous link and replace one lemon slice with a blood orange slice and the parsley with fennel fronds.


Fish broiled in the Adriatic way

Before our Christmas Eve grew, we would present the secondi of fish broiled in the Adriatic way, a reference to the Adriatic Sea that borders Puglia and the traditions of that region. If you have not guessed by now, the DiPippa family name comes from Puglia. This is delicious, but it can be a tough dish to do for 20 people in a home kitchen.

Not cod, but you get the idea

Not cod, but you get the idea

Ingredients (for 4)
  • Four thick Cod steaks, approximately 4-6ounces each (Or a whole two pound fish, but we have never indulged quite that far)
  • Olive Oil
  • Juice of half a lemon
  • 1 Lemon, sliced into wedges for serving
  • ¾-1 Cup of fine unflavored breadcrumbs
  • Salt
  1. Lightly salt both sides of the fish, or fish steaks
  2. Add the lemon juice and ¼ Cup of olive oil to a platter and turn the fish or fish steaks in it to coat.
  3. Add the bread crumbs to the platter and turn the fish or fish steaks several more times until evenly coated and leave to marinate for 1-2 Hours. The breadcrumbs will absorb a lot of the extra oil and flavor as well as giving us a nice crunch by the time we are done.
  4. Preheat your Broiler to High or have your coals ready at least 15 minutes before you plan to start cooking.
  5. I prefer to broil the fish steaks in the oven with a wire rack to encourage a better crust formation. It is hard to gauge the time the cooking will take because it depends on the thickness of the fish, generally allow for approximately 10 minutes per inch of thickness.
  6. Broil 5-6” away from the heat source, flipping the fish halfway through the cooking.
  7. Place the fish straightaway on a platter and serve with lemon slices



The contorni are the side dishes that are served with the secondi which are mostly vegetables in different preparations. Sometimes we will cheat and put these out with the primo course, but in the traditional meal structure, these are served alongside the secondi.

Roasted Zucchini

This is a simple dish, as many of these dishes are, meaning that it can be prepared quickly and with little effort while the rest of the meal is being made. Zucchini are cut into spears, tossed with a little olive oil, salt, and pepper, and then sprinkled with freshly grated parmigiana regiano before getting a few minutes under the broiler.IMG_4827

  • 2 Medium Zucchini
  • Parmagiana Regiano to grate
  • Olive Oil, maybe a tablespoon
  • Salt
  • Pepper
  1. Wash the Zucchini and cut into eight pieces in long spears. Start by halving the zucchini lengthwise and then, with the cut-side down, cut into four long spears. Repeat with the other half of the zucchini
  2. In a large bowl, toss the zucchini spears with the oil until lightly but evenly coated.
  3. Arrange on a lined baking sheet and sprinkle with salt and pepper
  4. Grate parmigiana regiano to taste onto the zucchini
  5. Broil for ~5 minutes, or until the cheese is golden brown and delicious

Marsala Glazed Carrots

As another option for your contorni, you can glaze carrots with Marsala wine. Marsala wine is a Sicilian wine that is usually sweetened and fortified wine for export. For this dish, you certainly want a sweeter version because we are after the sugars. If you read our French Week, this recipe is pretty much the same as the glazed root vegetables, but we are replacing butter and sugar with olive oil and Marsala wine.



  • 1lb Baby Carrots or Carrots in a thick battonet. You can prep these at the same time you prepped the Tasty Carrots in the Antipasti. Keep this batch refrigerated in an ice bath overnight.
  • 3Tbsp + 1Tbsp Olive Oil
  • ¼ Cup Marsala Wine
  • 1Tbsp Chopped Parsley
  • 1/4 Cup Chicken Stock



  1. In a large frying pan, heat 2TBSP of the olive oil until shimmering over medium heat.
  2.  Add the vegetables, tossing to coat the vegetables
  3.  Add the stock and Marsala, cover and simmer for ~10 minutes
  4.  Uncover and continue to evaporate remaining stock, tossing or stirring to keep the vegetables from sticking.
  5.  Remove from heat, add the parsley and last tablespoon of olive oil.  Stir or toss to coat.

Wine Pairings

Last time, we looked at a red option or two for the meal, so we will turn our attention here to the white wines available. It is possible you could have prosecco left from the antipasti period, and you could use that here for a nice addition. Another white wine grape often used in Southern Italy is malvasia but most of the white wines from Puglia you will find are “table wine” blends:

IMG_5788Similarly to our discussion in the Primo post, when you can’t find the regional wines, look again to Spain and for grapes like Albarino:


Before we move on to dessert , after the secondi, a bit of a palate cleanse in needed so the cheese and salad course fits in here.

Insalata e formaggio

We combine the salad and cheese course with a Caprese salad, while tomatoes may be out of season here, the additional iconography of an Italian Flag, with the red, white, and green, makes up for that. Remember, this dinner was as much about marking our heritage in the absence of a large Italian-American community, as anything else. This is a simple combination of good ingredients that is recognizable to nearly anyone.IMG_7302

 Caprese salad (serves 8)

  • 1lb Mozarella
  • 2 Large Tomaotes
  • Fresh Basil
  • Extra Virgin Olive Oil
  1. Slice the tomatoes and mozzarella into ¼ to ½” rounds.
  2. Arrange the cheese and tomatoes with fresh basil leaves in an overlapping pattern, like the Italian flag.
  3. Drizzle a little extra-virgin olive oil and add a sprinkling of salt.

Another option for the Insalata comes from Sicily and is a refreshing and palate cleansing salad:

Citrus and Fennel Salad

Remember the fennel fronds we used in the pesce con cartocchio? This is probably where they came from! We will use the raw fennel and citrus with this Sicilian inspired salad to help ease things out of the meal.

  • 4 Oranges
  • 2 Fennels Bulbs
  • Scallions
  • 4TBSP Olive Oil
  • 1TBSP lemon juice
  • Salt
  • Basil
  1. Break down the fennel bulbs by cutting the fennel bulb in half, lengthwise, and cutting across halved bulb. If the fennel is too large compared to the orange slices, cut the fennel slices in half again.
  2. Break down the oranges by cutting away the peel and all of the pith. Slice the oranges into rounds and then halve those rounds.
  3. Prepare the dressing, whether with a whisk in a bowl or by using an empty condiment bottle by combining the olive oil, lemon juice, a pinch of salt, and maybe some dried basil until an emulsion forms.
  4. Toss the orange slices and fennel slices together and spoon the dressing around the edges of the bowl. Toss again to coat the orange and fennel with the dressing.
  5. Add some chopped scallions to the salad for garnish.

Previous Entries:

The Feast of the Seven Fishes

Seven Fishes – Antipasti e appertivo

Seven Fishes – I Primi

Upcoming Entries:

Seven Fishes – Dolce e digestivi